Netanyahu has found himself embroiled in a scandal which all the evidence suggests was created by himself or his chief of staff, Ido Norden. His rival Eisenkot says that Bibi should not remain in the Prime Minister’s seat for a single minute longer. The allegation is that the chief of staff contacted Shin Bet regarding possible electoral fraud within the Islamist party Ra’am. Fourteen police officers visited three candidates, searched their homes without a warrant and took them into custody.
An envelope containing thousands of shekels (the Israeli currency) was found, and the allegations were that Ra’am was buying votes.
Ra’am and the other Arab party, the United List, achieved record support and secured a total of 19 seats out of 120. There is a deadlock between the two blocs in Israeli politics, and the Arab parties hold the balance of power. Ra’am has said it is willing to support Eisenkot.
This would be historic, and Netanyahu has portrayed it as an attempt to undermine Israel from within.
However, he may have shot himself in the foot, as the allegations that prompted the police to intervene turned out to be unfounded.
Accusations have been levelled by both other parties and the judiciary that Netanyahu attempted to manipulate the election.
It is considered unlikely that Ido Norden acted in good faith when he contacted the police:
Channel 12’s investigative program Uvda reported that an initial complaint against activists for the Ra’am party that led to the arrests of three southern Bedouin men at dawn on election day, October 27, was supplied to police by Netanyahu’s chief of staff, Ido Norden, a day before the vote.
On the eve of the elections, Norden allegedly told the office of Israel Police Commissioner Daniel Levy about a purported effort by activists for the conservative-Islamist Ra’am party to pay Arab voters to boost turnout at polling stations.
This is a very serious allegation, and devastating for confidence in the government, which has many enemies within the judiciary. Now Netanyahu and his chief of staff may have handed them a gift.
The tip-off that led to the arrests came before the polling stations opened. This could be interpreted as an attempt to influence the election.
Hours after Norden allegedly tipped off the police and hours before polling stations would open, 14 police officers descended on the homes of three men in southern Israel, searching them without a warrant, based solely on information police had received from Netanyahu’s chief of staff and the former employee in his office, the report said. The former employee was not named in the report.
News of the arrests and the discovery of the money dominated the headlines and helped to undermine confidence in the election.
Though the arrests and subsequent investigation have produced little or nothing of substance, according to multiple reports on the state of police’s efforts, and prompted no indictments, they served to undermine public confidence in the vote and were swiftly used by the prime minister to allege the election had been stolen by Arab parties.
It was a serious allegation that the investigation did not substantiate. Quite the contrary. A court released one of the arrested Bedouins, stating that the arrest was unprecedented.
Attorney General Gali Baharav-Miara and the police’s special anti-corruption unit have launched an investigation into the Prime Minister’s office.
However, surveillance of Arab candidates was also initiated.
Separately, Channel 12 reported that Shin Bet chief David Zini sought on election day to wiretap five Arab lawmakers in connection with separate suspicions, made public two days later, of foreign interference in the election — an investigation whose announcement sent shockwaves through the country, but which has also seemingly fizzled out.
The Attorney General’s Office “was horrified by the request and fended it off,” the report said.
The question being raised is whether the government has now begun to use the security services and the police for political manipulation.
The government attempted to use the allegations of vote-buying and possible foreign interference to prevent the election from being certified. However, on 8 November, President Herzog tasked Eisenkot with forming a government.
The support for the two Arab parties has shocked Israel.
Arab turnout in Israeli elections has historically been low, with the turnout (some 77 percent) at last month’s election being the highest in 30 years. The two main Arab parties won an unprecedented 19 of the Knesset’s 120 seats.
For comparison, voter turnout was 53% among Arab Israelis in 2022, and just 44.6% in 2021, according to Reichman University’s Institute for Policy and Strategy.
If the Arabs turn out to vote, they could decide the election. That is an unfamiliar thought.
Netanyahu’s hope was that the political deadlock would lead to a snap election, in which he would stand a good chance. That possibility now appears to be slipping away. Attorney General Bali Bahahrav-M Miara says she has seen nothing that appears to be criminal.
Eisenkot added:
“Netanyahu and his associates’ conduct poses a tangible, direct and immediate threat to Israeli democracy,” he said in a statement.
“Under no circumstances must Netanyahu be allowed to remain at the helm of government for even one minute longer,” added Eisenkot. “Under no circumstances must Israel be dragged into another round of elections with him as prime minister. It is clear that as long as he remains in office, there will be no more fair elections. This is the main consideration guiding me in the coalition negotiations I am now conducting.”
Bibi’s manoeuvring could backfire on him and lead to the first government to be formed with the support of one or two Arab parties.
The Democrats chairman Yair Golan said the report “proves that Netanyahu’s office crossed yet another red line.”
“It is not just another dirty election trick. This is a suspected abuse of state power to undermine the democratic process. A real danger,” he wrote on X, urging immediate investigation.
B’Yachad no. 2 Yair Lapid retorted: “So there was an attempt to steal the election. It was orchestrated by the Likud from inside Netanyahu’s office.”
