Less than two years into Ronald Reagan’s first term as president, it seemed as though everything was, in a way, heading in the wrong direction. It’s hard for us to remember that now, but that’s how it was. After his first two years in office, it seemed as though things were heading in the wrong direction. He had won a landslide victory. He was hailed as a conservative – a victory hailed as a conservative revolution that turned the political establishment on its head. He was carried into office with an ambitious political mandate, he survived an assassination attempt, and he immediately delivered on a key election pledge – namely, a historic tax cut – and he did all this within the first eight months of his presidency.
But by early 1982 – when, incidentally, I think I was in Year 6 – the celebrations had given way to a growing sense of gloom. The Reagan administration was facing its first major political crisis. In less than a year, the Reagan administration’s approval rating had plummeted by 25 points, from 68 per cent down to 43 per cent. In March 1982 – just think for a moment about what I’m about to tell you – President Reagan was four points less popular than Jimmy Carter had been at the same stage of his term in office. The economy had gone into freefall. In fact, it was facing a full-blown recession. Unemployment was approaching double figures – the worst in 40 years – and many, rightly or wrongly, blamed the President for all of this. Even his foreign policy ambitions were beginning to lose ground, as growing fears of nuclear war with Russia fuelled a popular backlash against his efforts to combat Soviet communism around the world.
On all fronts, the Reagan administration and the conservative movement were on the defensive at that time. But it was against the backdrop of what I have just described to you from 1982 – which, incidentally, also culminated in crushing defeats for the President’s parties in Congress – it was against this backdrop, amidst declining morale, fear and despair, that something new began to stir. And at that time, it was little more than just an idea. It took root in just a few law schools – usually – in the common rooms and lecture theatres of several law faculties. But soon, what was beginning to take shape would reshape the entire American political and legal landscape and change the nation’s course forever.
In April 1982, in the midst of everything I have just described to you, four law students organised a symposium on federalism in New Haven, Connecticut. Around 200 people attended. One of the speakers who attended was a 46-year-old professor from Chicago. His name was Antonin Scalia, and he highlighted a fundamental problem for the assembly. He said that conservatives had quite simply been in the minority at federal level for half a century. And, of course, nowhere was this more evident at the time than in the courts. The Republicans had won three of the last four presidential elections. Seven of the nine Justices of the Supreme Court at that time had been appointed by Republican presidents, and yet it did not seem as though any of this mattered particularly much.
Nine years earlier, the Court had handed down its ruling in the case of Roe v. Wade. Five of the seven votes in favour of the ruling came from judges appointed by Republicans. The majority opinion was written by a judge who had been nominated by President Richard Nixon. The most consistent conservative on that court was William Rehnquist, and he spent much of his time as the sole dissenting voice – to such an extent that his law clerks gave him a Lone Ranger action figure as a present.
At that time, there was only one major law school in the country that had a conservative student journal. Incidentally, that happened to be Harvard. It had been founded four years earlier. And the very term ‘originalism’ was only two years old, and it was not coined by an originalist. It was coined by a liberal professor at Stanford in an article written to criticise and refute the concept. Just a few years later, a sitting Supreme Court justice would dismiss this idea of originalism. He would dismiss it as, and I quote, ‘little more than arrogance disguised as humility’, and scornfully remark that its supporters were ‘people who have no knowledge of the historical sources’. Thus began the Federalist Society.
But their critics are no longer scoffing. The Federalist Society helped to transform and advance America, and there are many lessons we can draw from this success today. One of these lessons is that politics requires more than simply winning elections, because government is not the only source of political power. Power also lies in the universities. Power lies in the press. Power lies throughout civil society, in all the institutions that define and shape our understanding of ourselves as a nation and as a people. Every society – and I mean every society – has an elite, has a ruling class. And in our society, this class is not only to be found in the White House, not only in Congress or the courts; it is also to be found in academia, in influential think tanks and in non-governmental organisations. It is found in boardrooms and executive suites, in think tanks and journals, in foundations and in the mass media, and spans the most important sectors of business, education and culture.
To be honest, this is something the left has often understood better than the right over the past six decades. Elections determine who holds office for a given term. But elections do not, of their own accord, determine what our institutions teach or what our legal experts believe, which ideas are treated as respectable or normal, and which are regarded as unacceptable. The government can, of course, play – and does play – a decisive role in shaping these things. But the government cannot fundamentally change them in two, four or eight years. That sort of change takes place over the course of a generation or more, and even then only through the dedicated work of a coalition of allies across institutions working together both within and outside the state.
The Federalist Society’s successes have been built on this insight. It is not merely a matter of appointing capable judges to positions where they can interpret the law. It is about shaping the world in which they do this, about shaping the norms and values, the ideas and beliefs, the expectations and assumptions that underpin how they think, reason and act. Who defines these things and to what end – that is what power is all about. This is not unique to our country’s legal system. In the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, we have seen the same thing at close quarters within the realm of what is known as international law. We have heard the term ‘international law’ being used against almost every major foreign policy decision or initiative taken by this administration.
For example, when President Trump ordered our military to sink cartel boats in the Caribbean, we were told that this was a breach of international law. The first chief prosecutor at the bogus and illegal International Criminal Court (ICC) even accused us of crimes against humanity.
When US forces apprehended Nicolás Maduro, a fugitive from US justice, and brought him to the US to stand trial, we heard the same accusations from the highest levels of – I shall not call them anything nasty – the UN.
Even the enforcement of our immigration laws – yes, even the enforcement of our own immigration laws here on American soil – has come under this attack. Earlier this year, for example, organisations such as the ACLU submitted a petition to the UN requesting an investigation into the Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE)’s blatant violations of international law here in the US.
Over the past decade, we have been subjected to a ceaseless stream of allegations regarding the US’s alleged breaches of international rules and norms, ranging from our foreign policy to our border controls and even what they call our systemic racism. Even on the issue of abortion, for example, when Roe v. Wade was overturned by the Supreme Court in 2022, it was swiftly condemned by a group – yes, you guessed it – UN human rights experts, an oxymoron – as a breach of the US’s binding legal obligations under international law.
None of this has anything whatsoever to do with any real higher standard of justice. It is the result of the people who control the official bodies of global governance. It is the result of the vast network of non-governmental organisations and agencies staffed by international activists and bureaucrats, together with their supporters here in the US and around the world.
For this global elite, international law is not a neutral set of rules. International law is a tool for promoting their interests under the guise of universal principles. They are, for example, ardent defenders of democracy – until certain elections challenge their interests. They lecture us on the importance of sovereignty, whilst at the same time demanding that nations relinquish control over their borders and hand over their immigration laws to unelected international courts. They claim to oppose all forms of imperialism, conquest and domination, yet they seek to exercise authority over every single country and every single government on earth.
That is why President Trump took the unprecedented decision earlier this year to impose sanctions on the illegitimate International Criminal Court – a fake court which is an un-elected world court, and which claims to take precedence over the laws and constitutions of sovereign states, even those that have never acceded to it.
The American people have never agreed to submit to the ICC’s authority, but this court and its allies within the global bureaucracy have appointed themselves judge, jury and executioner of the international order, and rule over everything without being held to account – they rule over everything. They believe they have the right to rule over everyone, but they are accountable to no one, and are equipped with the power to investigate, indict, prosecute and imprison our citizens under laws to which we have neither consented nor have any control over.
They are welcome to try, I would say. But if they are foolish enough to try to impose their paper decrees on the American people, our response will likely be the same as that given by the Roman general Pompey when he spoke to those who tried to invoke the privileges of their cities against his legions. He said: ‘Stop quoting laws to men with swords.’ It’s not politically correct to say that, but that’s what he said.
In any case: using international law as a weapon is not entirely unlike what we’ve seen here at home. The activist courts that seek to govern through judicial rulings, and which twist the law to suit whatever their preferences might be at a given place or time; their allies in academia, in the press, the professional activist class – the very same people who, just a few years ago, condemned the Constitution, didn’t they? These are the same people who, just a few years ago, denounced the Constitution as a racist and reactionary document written by slave-owners, solely to protect the interests of rich white men.
Those same people are now speaking in grand terms about how they are defending our principles of government and how they are carrying out their constitutional duties. For these people, the fundamental purpose of the law – both US law and international law – is to weaken the United States. It is to undermine our power as a sovereign nation to act. It is to hinder the US government’s ability to defend American interests both at home and abroad. They tell us that we are bound by a sacred legal obligation to surrender our power, surrender our sovereignty, submit to the whims of our enemies, allow our cities to descend into violent anarchy, welcome any foreigner from anywhere in the world who arrives at our doorstep without permission, and turn our cities into refugee camps for the entire globe. And even beyond our borders, they would have us believe that we must allow our rivals to act against us with impunity, that those who flood our country with drugs, crime and death should be met with little more than the odd polite complaint. There is nothing – absolutely nothing – in our history or in the history of any other great nation that requires us to recognise the authority or legitimacy of any of these ridiculous ideas.
On the contrary – it is not merely alien to our political and legal tradition; it is alien to who we are. It is an attack on our very essence as a people, a rejection of the qualities and instincts that have characterised Americans since before the nation’s very founding. America has always been, and will, I believe, always be, a nation of indomitable ambition – an ambition that, from the very beginning, reached far beyond our borders. Limitations and narrow horizons have never been our destiny. Even the American Revolution was partly driven by our forefathers’ anger at British restrictions on our westward expansion – a grievance mentioned in the Declaration of Independence itself. The history of our nation and our people is full of a hunger to expand, to grow, to explore, to conquer, to claim new frontiers. This is, incidentally, found in the opening paragraph of the ‘Federalist Papers’, where Hamilton begins by telling readers that the ratification debate would determine the fate of an empire – in many ways the most interesting in the world.
We, the Americans, are not a passive, inward-looking people. To submit to the sterile vision of radical judges or soulless global bureaucrats would be to betray who we are, to betray ourselves. The real America – the nation that actually exists in the text of our founding documents, that actually exists in the history of our people, in the conduct of the men who transformed remote colonies into the greatest superpower on earth, was always destined to go further, to become greater and stronger, more than had ever been before. Our laws, our Constitution, our legal norms and our political traditions developed because of – not in spite of – this fact.
This is the true American genius of self-government, the unique and distinctive structure of our Constitution, which unites a remarkable freedom and independence with an equally remarkable capacity for collective action. It is the expression of these qualities and instincts that our institutions were designed to organise and channel our ambition, not to stifle it. Our laws were written by and for a people who were called upwards and, ultimately, even outwards towards the stars.
From the very beginning, America was on the move. It was alive, it was dynamic, and it was growing – a nation advancing across the continent, settling new territories, building cities, laying roads and railways, taming the wilderness and creating a great civilisation on the canvas of a new world.
In 1776, our new republic consisted of 13 states clustered along the east coast and a handful of scattered frontier outposts just beyond the Appalachians. By 1848 – and this is very recent – just 72 years later, the American flag flew over a continental empire stretching across nearly 3 million square miles, from the eastern cities of Boston and New York to the harbours of San Francisco Bay. So think of it this way: a child born in the year we declared our independence could have lived long enough to see their country stretch from the Atlantic to the Pacific.
And as our territory expanded, our horizons grew ever wider. No sooner had we reached the western edge of Oregon than we began building new systems, networks and technologies that spanned the globe; digging canals across continents that redefined the rules of geography; and developing satellites and spacecraft that reached beyond the very boundaries of Earth itself. None of this happened by chance.
When our forebears first arrived in North America, when they first came here, there were no factories, no railways and no skyscrapers. These things exist because we built them, because we took action. These things exist because we acted without fear or moral hesitation and overcame everything that threatened us or stood in our way.
But today we are told by some that the era when great nations strove for grand destinies is over, that we cannot act, that we cannot impose ourselves on the world, that we must surrender our dreams to the consensus of distant tribunals and accept our place as just one nation amongst many, that we must resign ourselves to a comfortable and quiet decline. We are told that our willingness to act in our own interests, on our own terms, is an attack on the universal, so-called ‘rules-based order’.
According to this theory, for example, the President cannot himself conduct US foreign policy; he cannot impose trade or immigration restrictions, or even investigate how we spend our citizens’ tax money abroad, without facing fierce criticism from international advocates, lawyers, non-governmental organisations and UN bureaucrats who condemn his threats to global values and norms.
All of this, both at home and abroad, is a product of the levelling and pessimistic spirit of the times. It tempts us to relinquish responsibility for our own destiny, to free ourselves from the burdens of greatness and seek refuge in these glittering generalisations within international law. Although we defeated Soviet communism as an institution, we did not triumph over the spirit of Marx. The Marxist spirit lives on. It lives on in these new forms and doctrines, which seek to subordinate the national will to a global consensus. Marxism sought to abolish the differences between people. The radicals of our time seek to abolish the differences between nations themselves.
The crucial question of our time is whether Americans have a moral right to exist as a separate nation and a separate people, and thus to demand a government that defends and safeguards our interests above all else. Those who, for example, tell us that we live on stolen land, that our nation was founded and built on slavery, genocide and oppression, are clearly telling us that they do not believe we have that right. They want us to believe that the American way – that America – and, in a broader sense, that the West – is uniquely burdened by guilt, a guilt we can only atone for through total capitulation – by opening our borders, by renouncing our laws, by withdrawing from the world and letting them reshape our society in their own image.
We must understand quite clearly that this – precisely this – is what is at stake in our political struggle. We must remember that this is what many in academia, in the courts or in government circles truly believe. As recently as 2021, we had a president who told us that hatred – hatred – was systemically embedded in our laws and culture. Today, few, if any, of these people on that side of the political debate have distanced themselves from these ideas.
Their fundamental convictions have not changed. And over the coming months, we can expect to hear a great deal about their deep concern for the constitution, the law, the principles of justice and fundamental principles. But this concern seems to surface only when it can be used as an obstacle or a weapon to further their own interests.
Politics – both here in the US and on the international stage – is, frankly, not a marketplace of ideas where interlocutors can debate and reason together in good faith, and where the best argument always prevails. Conviction is important, but not everyone can always be persuaded. The lesson from the Federalist Society is that victory requires more than just good arguments. Victory is secured through institutions, networks and systems that are focused on a common goal, and which are capable of shaping and exerting influence.
This organisation’s long march through the American judicial institutions was carried out by men and women who were equipped not only with ideas, but also with ambitious plans of action. They nurtured and recruited the most promising young conservative minds of their generation, guided them along career paths towards power, and took their cause from the lecture theatres to the nation’s highest courts.
Those who believe that a single setback, a single defeat or a poor election result spells the end of the republic should look to you as a role model and draw inspiration from you. And, incidentally, that is the very same lesson woven into the very fabric of our country – a lesson woven into the very fabric of our revolution, the one that gave birth to this nation.
All too often, we tell the story of American independence as an inevitable and certain victory, as if Washington and the Continental Army were always destined to triumph. Those who have studied our history know that nothing could be further from the truth. The first year of the Revolution was an almost unbroken series of devastating and humiliating defeats. By December 1776, General Washington had fewer than 3,000 men fit for service – limping, starving, freezing and sick – and they were in desperate retreat, with the greatest empire of the age hot on their heels. Throughout the colonies, it seemed as though the spirit of the Revolution was on the verge of collapse.
In fact, there is something that is rarely highlighted in films, documentaries and perhaps even in books about this era: thousands of Americans accepted a British pardon and renewed their allegiance to the Crown. That is how dire the situation was. Men who, just a few months earlier, had cheered for the cause of independence, resigned themselves to what seemed like an inevitable defeat.
That month, Washington wrote a letter to his brother. He said that unless something changed soon, he wrote, ‘I believe it is quite near the end.’ And he concluded the letter with this. He said – and this is a quote – ‘You, who are so far away, cannot imagine how bewildering my situation is. I believe no one has ever faced a greater array of difficulties and had fewer means of extricating themselves from them than I have. But as I am fully convinced that our cause is just, I cannot help but believe that the prospects will brighten, even though, for wise reasons, they are at present hidden behind a cloud.”
Well, he was proved right in the end. Five years later, Washington – and, we must admit, his French allies – surrounded the British army at Yorktown; Cornwallis surrendered; the Revolution triumphed; and a nation was born. We have much more to do over the next two, the next six, the next 20 years. Great things that endure are built up over decades, not electoral terms. There will be more victories, and there will be more defeats. There will be more triumphs, and there will be more disappointments. Such is the nature of all undertakings of this weight and scope. There are no great men or great causes in the pages of history who have not gone through the same. But we are convinced of the justice of our cause, and we, too, will ultimately prevail.
And whilst we are prepared for the twists and turns and the ups and downs of the road that lies ahead, I believe with all my heart that we, in this generation, will leave to our children and grandchildren what Americans always leave to their children and grandchildren: the greatest nation in world history.