The Supreme Court has overturned Hamse Ali’s 45-day prison sentence for giving false evidence. The case has now been referred back to the Court of Appeal. Hamse Ali claimed that he was attacked in Nygårdsparken in the autumn of 2024 and severely beaten. However, the investigation revealed that he had not even been in the park on the day in question.
Hamse Ali’s story sparked widespread public interest. The police put an end to that interest. He was no innocent victim.
The District Court believed Hamse Ali. But in the Court of Appeal, the court believed the expert witness who stated that he did not believe the case involved false memories. Hamse Ali was sentenced to 45 days.
The Supreme Court has quashed the sentence because the question is whether it is a criminal offence to maintain a statement that protects one from self-incrimination. ‘Is one allowed to lie to the police to avoid punishment?’ is the question.
The case was no longer about false memories, but about whether Ali could give an incorrect account during a follow-up interview without being punished for it.
In short: Is it actually illegal to lie to the police during an interview if one incriminate oneself by telling the truth?
The Supreme Court could choose to acquit him or ask the Court of Appeal to re-examine the case.
The Supreme Court has now concluded that the Court of Appeal’s judgement is to be set aside.
https://www.nrk.no/artikkel/hogsterett-opphevar-fengselsdommen-for-uriktig-forklaring-1533436
