Over 100,000 telephone calls made directly to civilians in Gaza. 9.3 million leaflets.
One and a half million text messages and 17 million automated calls, all with the same message to get to safety before the bombs fall.
It is the Israeli Defence Forces that have done this, and this is not how one proceeds if the aim is to exterminate a people.
Genocide, after all, is intended to exterminate an ethnic group, in whole or in part. Without this intent, it is not genocide, no matter how brutal the war may be. John Spencer, who heads the studies in urban warfare at the US Military Academy at West Point, believes that no army in history has done more to spare civilians than Israel has done in Gaza.
Over 74,000 have died, according to the Ministry of Health in Gaza. But it is Hamas that controls the ministry, and Hamas includes everything in its tally: its own fighters, of whom Israel estimates there are around 25,000. People who died of illness and old age – 5,000–6,000 a year, even before the war began. And people killed by Hamas itself, or by Hamas rockets that fell within Gaza, as the British think tank the Henry Jackson Society has concluded.
The Israeli Jerusalem Centre has calculated that at most 41,000 civilians have died from war-related causes. The ICGS institute estimates that for every terrorist killed, 1–1.7 civilians were killed, and that this is the lowest ratio known from any war in densely populated areas anywhere.
Many media outlets have also reported that the International Court of Justice in The Hague has found a ‘probable genocide’. This is incorrect, and it was the Court’s own President at the time of the ruling, Joan Donoghue, who had to set the record straight. The court ordered Israel to prevent acts that could fall under the Genocide Convention, but it has never taken a position on whether genocide has in fact taken place.
That case could take several years.
The war began when Hamas killed around 1,200 people in Israel and took 251 people hostage on 7 October 2023.
