Stephan Sander-Faes is a professor of history at the University of Bergen; he is originally from Austria. An article in *Der Standard* on 5 November accuses him of holding revisionist views regarding the Holocaust, Israel and Germany. *Khrono* picked up on the story, but unfortunately neither *Der Standard* nor *Khrono* reproduce the original quotations in their full context.
What emerges suggests that Sander-Faes is willing to question the existence of extermination camps, which is a well-documented fact. If so, he has gone down the same path as David Irving. To question well-established facts, particularly in such a sensitive matter, suggests a lack of restraint and judgement.
Sander-Faes compares historical events with contemporary politics. He writes, for example, about the expulsion of Germans from East Prussia at the end of the Second World War. Around 11 million Germans were driven westwards and around two million died. This has been the standard view. Now, ChatGPT states that the figures vary.
However, it is important to distinguish between the number of displaced people and the number who died.
After the Second World War, around 12–14 million ethnic Germans were forced to flee or were expelled from their homes in Eastern and Central Europe.
This included, in particular, Germans from East Prussia, Silesia, Pomerania, the Sudetenland and other areas of Czechoslovakia, Poland, Hungary and Yugoslavia.
The traditional West German estimate was around 2 million deaths, but this figure is disputed. More recent demographic and historical research has produced lower estimates for deaths directly linked to flight and expulsion.
This is a little-known tragedy. It is understandable that those who were affected and lived in the shadow of this displacement cannot forget. But when one goes on to draw comparisons with Israel’s policy towards the Palestinians, the picture becomes skewed.
This is what Sander-Faes does on his Substack account ‘Fackel’ under the pseudonym epimetheus.
The Sander-Faes scandal began in his home country, Austria. But as he teaches in Bergen, Khrono took up the case. Vice-Chancellor Margareth Hagen initially stated that Sander-Faes has freedom of expression. But when the case attracted international attention and reactions from both the Israeli embassy and academic colleagues, she changed her tune. Sander-
Faes was suspended from teaching. Sander-Faes’s academic position was tenuous. He was unable to justify his revisionist views academically.
Norway has become revisionist
The problem is that the Norwegian public has been affected by the same reinterpretation of history as Sander-Faes. The view of Israel has changed to such an extent that it is up for review. Is there a genocide against the Palestinians? If so, it must be legitimate to discuss and analyse when it began.
In that case, the Norwegian public is heading towards a reality just as distorted as the one Sander-Faes finds himself in.
The affinity for Hamas and Gaza is driven by the same moralising that Sander-Faes displays when he compares the expulsion of Germans after 1945 with that of Palestinians from Palestine.
The Norwegian elite is no longer immune to anti-Semitism.
This becomes clear when people such as Anine Kierulf defend both Bassam Hussein’s and Sander-Faes’ right to celebrate 7 October and deny the existence of the death camps, which are the very symbol of the Holocaust.
The dismantling of history
We are talking about the dismantling of both history and contemporary history.
Kierulf pointed out that, under the 2015 Penal Code, the glorification of violence is no longer prohibited in Norway. It is therefore legal to glorify acts of terrorism that have been committed, as Bassam Hussein did regarding 7 October when he called it “the most beautiful thing that has happened in our century”.
On the one hand, the PST (Norwegian Police Security Service) is issuing warnings that extremism and the glorification of violence are on the rise, both in Islamist circles and on the dark web, where morbid groups incite their members to commit grotesque acts of violence. On the other hand, a Norwegian professor can, with the law on his side, claim that the glorification of violence is lawful.
This is evidence of a society that has dismantled all preventive barriers against terror and violence.
Those academics who argue that Muslims and their faith must be respected have no qualms about relativising the Holocaust and celebrating 7 October.
2+2=4. This lays the groundwork for new attacks on Jews and Christians.
When freedom of expression becomes absolute, anything is possible:
— Denying the Holocaust is not prohibited. If a member of staff at a Norwegian university is a Holocaust denier in their spare time, they are fully entitled to be so. It is not a matter for the university, says Kierulf, a professor of law at the University of Oslo.
This is the European disease rearing its head. In the US, where freedom of speech under Trump is strong – which it was not under Obama and Biden – it is illegal to incite hatred against either Jews or Christians.
But it is permitted in today’s Europe, and academics such as Kierulf and Tor Grande at NTNU pretend that they are defending tolerance.
Hierarchy of values
If one fails to see this, one is not being honest about it and cannot claim ignorance.
If history is to have any value, it must be because it has something to teach us.
Laurence Rees titled one of his books on Nazism A warning from history.
Now it seems as though people are passively or actively forgetting this warning.
What ghosts?
Margareth Hagen won’t say anything, and the Vice-Chancellor of NTNU, Tor Grande, won’t comment on Bassam Hussein either.
People are wringing their hands.
In Cappelen’s review of Hans Olav Lahlum’s children’s book about the Second World War, it states:
‘81 years after the end of the Second World War, the ghosts of Nazi ideology still lurk in our own streets, and the importance of understanding history is perhaps greater now than ever.’
‘Never again!’ today means ‘we want the right to define who it is that will repeat those atrocities’. Perhaps it is the Jews this time? There are many signs pointing in that direction, and it is official Norwegian foreign policy to bring Netanyahu and Yigal Allon before an international court for war crimes.
The International Criminal Court (ICC) does not respect the fact that Israel has not ratified the ICC. The Court and the signatory states, including Norway, have nevertheless issued arrest warrants for them worldwide.
The country that was attacked by Hamas, Hezbollah and Iran is itself wanted for war crimes.
In the political gravitational field, Europe is being drawn towards the dark sources of ancient and modern history, and the two histories taught at the universities of Bergen and Trondheim show that the enemy is already within the walls.
