Negotiations on the national budget are dragging on past the deadline, with no prospect of an agreement at the time of writing. The question is whether the Støre government has any real parliamentary basis at all, or whether the Labour Party is in fact governing on a contrived basis through an impossible political balancing act.
The balancing act that must be maintained – assuming the government’s political basis actually exists – is to reconcile the MDG’s climate demands with the Centre Party’s ultimatum on lower petrol and diesel prices. Given that, during last year’s negotiations, the MDG managed to secure nothing more than a few crumbs in the form of cheaper monthly travel passes for public transport, this year’s climate demands appear more like an absolute requirement and thus something close to an ultimatum.
Opposites
Politically speaking, the party is closely aligned with the Socialist Left Party (SV) on climate issues, but as far removed from the Centre Party (Sp) as it is possible to be in Norwegian politics. And since the Labour Party (Ap) is entirely dependent on securing the support of the Centre Party (Sp) to gain a majority for the national budget, whilst also ensuring a ‘yes’ vote from the Green Party (MDG), there is every reason to wonder what sort of substantial horse-trading will now be required to secure a majority for next year’s budget. Given that the Socialist Party’s next demands are further billions for the local authorities and a clearer focus on rural areas – issues that are not a ‘priority’ for the Green Party – we could, for that matter, simply continue to list the disagreements between the two parties…
Most likely, we’ll also have to make use of next week and, during that time, come up with something the MDG can accept. If not, the supporting parties ‘on the fence’ will gain absolutely nothing and be left empty-handed after this year’s negotiations, whilst Rødt and SV will reasonably reap the rewards of their somewhat more realistic demands on tax and redistribution policy – at least compared with MDG’s, if not so much with the SP’s far more populist demands on petrol and diesel.
As backwards as it may sound: neither the SP nor the MDG will bring down the government, even if the parties have to go home with their heads bowed – in shame. The MDG might perhaps want to, but… no, hardly.
The SP calls the shots
The Labour Party (Ap) originally wanted the Socialist Left Party (SV) on board in the previous government, of which the SP was a part. Here, Trygve Slagsvold Vedum put his foot down, firmly. Either Jonas Gahr Støre would govern with him and the SP, or that was that. The SP would have done the same if it had been the MDG that the Ap wanted in the government.
But the Labour Party is not exactly keen on having the MDG – a brake on industry and the oil and gas sector – in government either; that is more or less out of the question. So, of the parties supporting the government, it is the MDG that is in the weakest position. But, purely mathematically, the Labour Party is dependent on both of them (the SP has nine and the MDG eight MPs in the Storting) to secure a majority, whether on the national budget or any other matters of significance. And as we can see, they do not have that. So here, the SP actually has far more say than the election result would suggest – which is not unexpected.
Political stumbling block
Many governments in Europe have put together similar impossible coalitions or arrangements with supporting parties that are deeply divided on most issues, simply to defeat an enemy they fear even more.
Look at France and the sidelining of the Rassemblement National (RN) and Marine Le Pen, and look to Germany with the AfD (Alternative für Deutschland). Both parties have long vied to be the largest in their respective countries, but are kept out of central government by political manoeuvring. Le Pen was, in fact, branded a political pariah and barred from participating in French politics not so long ago. Her ‘case’ has not yet been finally settled, despite her powerful ‘comeback’.
So what about Norway? Isn’t what is going on here a contrived manoeuvre between political enemies to keep the FrP out of power in this country? When the so-called consensus amongst the four supporting parties depends on the MDG and the Sp coming to an agreement, the answer is clear. This is parliamentary trickery and will be judged accordingly.
