In Scotland, a driver was charged with making racist remarks whilst driving alone with his four-year-old son. The remarks were in response to the driver in front of him, who nearly crashed into his car and appeared to be under the influence of alcohol. When the police received the video footage, they charged the man who reported the reckless driving, rather than investigating the driver. Reason? Racism trumps all other crimes in Scotland.
The Free Speech Union reports that one of its members was charged by the police after he had submitted video evidence of the dangerous driving. He was, naturally, surprised that a few words uttered in desperation at nearly being run over by a driver who was clearly under the influence were not only considered worse than the dangerous driving itself, but that the police dropped the case against the driver and instead charged the man who had tried to assist them. As we all know, driving is one of the most dangerous things we can do, and road accidents claim thousands of lives worldwide every year. Uttering a few expletives inside one’s own car, without a public audience, has never killed anyone. Nevertheless, the police chose to devote resources to this.
It was in April 2025 that the man in question – who has chosen to remain anonymous; let’s call him ‘the father’ – – was driving his four-year-old son home to Glasgow from the funfair in Falkirk when another car suddenly cut in front of him as he was about to exit the motorway. The father had to swerve sharply to avoid a collision. He suspected that the driver of the other car was drunk and called the police.
When the police arrived, they chose not to test the suspected driver’s blood alcohol level, but took the video footage from the father to check whether any offence had been committed. A week later, he was contacted by the police and told that the only offence that had taken place was the one committed by the father.
Privacy: a thing of the past
What led to a charge was “smelly black bastard”, words which are, of course, unacceptable – in public. But is it a criminal offence to say something racist in your own car, with no audience other than your own child? That is clearly the view of the Scottish police. And this was the very thing people were warned against when the new hate crime legislation was introduced in 2021. If what is said within the four walls of one’s home, or as in this case: in one’s own car, can also be punished, there is no longer such a thing as privacy.
Fortunately, the father was acquitted, thanks to legal assistance from the Free Speech Union. But this is not the first time someone has been investigated for something said in a private context. The Free Speech Union recounts two truly hair-raising examples:
In one case, a couple were out horse riding with their fourteen-year-old daughter on a single-track country lane in Cambridgeshire when a car overtook them without slowing down. The mother made a rude gesture; the car skidded to a halt, and two travellers got out and began abusing her daughter. While on the phone to the police, the mother called one of the men a “pikey”. The police took no action against the men, but threatened to charge her with a “hate crime” unless she completed a racial awareness course. The FSU helped her find a lawyer, and the police took no further action.
