To avoid bias, political influence and a reluctance to tackle sensitive issues, Document asked KI to assess the police’s handling of the brutal home raid in Ullern, Oslo. The verdict is scathing.
The latest developments in the case, along with a summary of the case by Document, are set out below:
We provided KI with all the known facts of the case and asked for an assessment of the police’s work. In brief, it is as follows:
- The police’s handling of the case is described as a “potentially serious professional failure” and a “political scandal”.
- It is legitimate to investigate whether the police prosecutor’s political involvement could create conflicts of interest or undermine confidence in her impartiality.
- The case should be referred for an independent review, with particular emphasis on the release.
KI’s assessment and recommendation
This appears to be a potentially serious failure of police professionalism, with several features that could justify the term ‘political scandal’.
Nevertheless, I would distinguish between a documented political scandal and a case that raises such serious questions that it warrants an independent investigation.
It is, in particular, the combination of circumstances that makes this case serious:
– The robbery is said to have been planned and to have involved five people in different roles.
– One of the individuals is said to have carried out a reconnaissance mission at the family’s home three days before the robbery, under the guise of a Finn.no transaction.
– Three people are said to have carried out the robbery, whilst a fourth waited in the getaway car.
– The police arrested all five on the same day.
– They were released without being remanded in custody.
– After 40 days, four of the five have still not been questioned, according to the police’s own email.
The last point is particularly striking. The right to remain silent is not a right to avoid investigation.
1. The release must be assessed against two different grounds for detention
This is an important legal point which I believe deserves greater attention.
Section 171 of the Criminal Procedure Act permits remand in custody on grounds including:
– Risk of absconding.
– Specific risk of tampering with evidence.
– Risk of reoffending.
However, there is also a separate provision:
Section 172 of the Criminal Procedure Act – arrest for the purposes of law enforcement.
This allows for arrest even if the conditions in Section 171 are not met, provided that:
– The suspicion relates to an offence punishable by a minimum of ten years’ imprisonment, or aggravated assault / grievous bodily harm.
– There is a confession or other circumstances that particularly strengthen the suspicion.
In making this assessment, consideration shall be given, amongst other things, to whether the suspect remaining at large would offend the public’s sense of justice or create a sense of insecurity.
Aggravated robbery under Section 328 of the Penal Code carries a maximum sentence of 15 years’ imprisonment.
This means that Section 172 is a provision that should definitely be examined in this case.
It is not the case that five people should automatically be remanded in custody simply because the robbery is serious. However, if the suspicion is particularly well-founded, Section 172 may be relevant, even if the police consider that there is no risk of reoffending, absconding or tampering with evidence.
2. The investigation: 40 days without questioning
Here, I believe the police’s handling of the case raises even more striking questions.
The police state that four of the suspects do not wish to attend for questioning.
They are fully within their rights to refuse to make a statement.
However, it is important to distinguish between two things:
– The right to remain silent.
– The police’s responsibility to conduct an effective investigation.
The five individuals have already been identified and arrested. Furthermore, according to reports, the police have gained access to footage from the neighbour’s CCTV camera.
The police cannot force the suspects to speak, but that does not exempt them from investigating:
– Communication between the five before and after the robbery.
– Planning and division of roles.
– Any links between the reconnaissance and the robbery itself.
– Possible influence on the victims.
– Whether the suspects have been in contact with one another since their release.
It is also worth noting that the police do not need to wait for a suspect to voluntarily offer a statement before the investigation proceeds.
There is also an important addition: Section 230 of the Criminal Procedure Act was amended with effect from 1 July 2026. Under the new wording, a suspect may be summoned to the police station to clarify whether they wish to make a statement. In the event of a lawful summons and failure to appear without a valid reason, the prosecution may decide to have the suspect brought in. It is therefore incorrect to interpret the right to remain silent as a general right to ignore a police summons.
lovspor.
3. What about the safety of the victims?
In my opinion, this is one of the most serious aspects.
We are talking about a family who, according to the information provided:
– Have had their home invaded.
– Have been subjected to violence and deprivation of liberty.
– Have experienced a planned attack.
– Fear reprisals from the suspects.
When the police release all five suspects, there must also be an assessment of how the victims are to be protected.
The fact that the family does not dare to speak to the press is not in itself proof that the police have neglected their duty to protect them. However, it is a serious indication of the family’s perceived sense of safety.
The police should be able to explain which security measures have been considered and, where applicable, implemented.
4. The police prosecutor’s impartiality
We must be particularly careful here.
Information has been published regarding the police prosecutor’s political involvement and money transfers to private individuals in Gaza. Document has also reported that she was subsequently removed from the case.
It is legitimate to investigate whether her political involvement could have created a conflict of interest or undermined confidence in her impartiality.
However, based on the information publicly available here, there is no basis for concluding that her political stance influenced the decision to release the suspects.
This must be investigated, not assumed.
5. My assessment of the police’s handling of the case
I would use the following terms:
Issue My assessment
Release of all five A decision requiring a thorough explanation
Failure to consider Section 172 A significant issue
Four suspects not interviewed after 40 days Striking and, in my view, worrying
The victim is living in fear A serious safety issue
Possible conflict of interest Requires an independent assessment
My conclusion
I believe there are grounds to describe this as a potential political scandal and a serious failure on the part of the police in their handling of a serious criminal case.
It is not necessary to prove corruption or political motives for a political scandal to exist. Serious failings in the exercise of discretion, oversight and accountability can also constitute a political scandal.
However, I would not conclude that a criminal breach of duty has occurred without further documentation.
6. What should happen now?
I believe the case should be referred for an independent review, with particular emphasis on:
1. The grounds for the release of each individual suspect.
2. Whether Section 172 was taken into account.
3. Whether the police have pursued the investigation with the necessary diligence.
4. Whether the risk of reprisals against the family has been assessed.
5. Whether the police prosecutor’s impartiality was assessed prior to the decision to release.
Relevant supervisory bodies will be the Chief Constable, the management of the Oslo Police District, the Oslo Public Prosecutor’s Office and, where applicable, the Special Unit for Police Cases.
One final observation: it is particularly difficult to understand why the police cannot provide a more specific account of the progress of the investigation, whilst the four suspects themselves have stated that they do not wish to make a statement.
Their right to remain silent is inviolable. However, the police’s duty to investigate does not cease to exist for that reason.
It is precisely this distinction that I believe should be central to public scrutiny of the case.
