The robbers, who were released by a police lawyer and a Palestine activist, have still not been questioned, six weeks after their arrest. The police justify this by saying they do not wish to do so. KI calls this a «political scandal»
«….have stated that they do not wish to attend questioning at this stage»
This is what Rune Alstadsæter writes about the brutal robbers behind the home invasion, unlawful detention and violence.
He is the Director of Communications at the Oslo Police District. Some will remember him as a former NRK journalist and State Secretary to Prime Minister Erna Solberg.
Six weeks without questioning
Six weeks have passed since the premeditated and brutal home robbery took place, during which the robbers were arrested the same day, thanks to an alert neighbour with a camera who alerted the police.
The five suspects in the case avoided remand and are therefore at liberty, much to the concern of the victims.
Document asked KI to provide an assessment of the police’s work. It read:
“This appears to be a potentially serious failure of policing, with several features that could justify the term ‘police scandal’.”
Initially, just a brief report
On Monday 5 October, a family in Ullern, Oslo, endured the nightmare of being robbed in their own home. The robbery was premeditated. The victims were subjected to deprivation of liberty and violence.
Thanks to a vigilant neighbour with a camera, who alerted the police, the robbers were arrested the same day.
Despite the seriousness of the crime, this received only a small and somewhat misleading mention in the controversial, left-wing newspaper Dagbladet. The rest of the mainstream press ignored the story.
It transpired that a total of five people had been involved in the robbery – three robbers, a driver who was waiting in the getaway car and a «scout» who had visited the property the previous Friday.
On 26 October, Document described the scale of the case and revealed that the robbers had been released from custody, as well as important details about them.
Committed robbery, unlawful detention and assault, but walks free
On 28 October, Document revealed that the police prioritised the robbers’ freedom of movement over the victims’ freedom of expression.
The police prioritise criminals’ freedom of movement over victims’ freedom of speech
Far more serious
It then transpired that police prosecutor Mari Bystrøm Julnes, who made the decision that there was no need for pre-trial detention, is an active Palestine campaigner who operated under a partially concealed identity on Facebook.
Palestinian activist in the police force let the robbers go free
The police denied the allegations and issued threats
The police denied that Julnes was an activist. They referred to that description as Document’s “narrative”.
But the police went further. They accused Document of mixing journalism with opinion pieces. They threatened Document, claiming we had breached the Code of Conduct.
But when it emerged that Julnes was not only involved in pro-Palestine activism on Facebook, but had also organised a number of fundraising campaigns on Spleis and made money transfers to private individuals in Gaza via PayPal, she was taken off the case.
Julnes has also deleted or deactivated her Facebook page.
“Serious failure on the part of the police”
Document put the following question to the police:
-Have the five robbers been questioned or not?
The question was phrased in this way because we had asked the same thing previously without receiving a reply. The new police prosecutor who took over from Julnes was unaware of the status. We received the following reply on Friday 13 November:
«The Hjemmeran case is currently under investigation. The police have interviewed witnesses, carried out technical investigations in the area and searched for video footage and photographs from the scene. One of the suspects has indicated that he wishes to attend an interview, and the police will endeavour to arrange an interview as soon as practicable. The four others who have been charged haveindicated that they do not wish to attend an interview at this stage. One has the right to remain silent – and not to make a statement during questioning in criminal cases – but the police wish to interview these individuals at a later date.»
Director of Communications Alstadsæter gives the impression that it is up to the criminals whether they wish to attend questioning or not.
Six weeks have passed since the arrest and, in practice, the resolution of the robbery itself. However, whether the perpetrators are behind similar unsolved and/or dismissed cases, or whether they are part of a criminal network, does not seem to be of further interest.
To avoid any biased assessment of the police’s work so far in this case, we presented the facts to KI. We received the following verdict:
This appears to be a potentially serious failure of police professionalism, with several features that could justify the term ‘police scandal’.
I would nevertheless draw a distinction between a documented political scandal and a case that raises such serious questions that it warrants an independent investigation.
It is, in particular, the combination of circumstances that makes the case serious:
– The robbery is said to have been planned and to have involved five people in various roles.
– One of the individuals is said to have carried out a reconnaissance mission at the family’s home three days before the robbery, under the guise of a Finn.no transaction.
– Three people are said to have carried out the robbery, whilst a fourth waited in the getaway car.
– The police arrested all five on the same day.
– They were released without being remanded in custody.
– After 40 days, four of the five have still not been questioned, according to the police’s own email.
This last point is particularly striking. The right to remain silent is not a right to avoid investigation.
Furthermore, KI points out:
It is not necessary to prove corruption or political motives for a political scandal to exist. Serious failures in the exercise of discretion, oversight and accountability can also constitute a political scandal.
The full judgement from KI, including its recommendations, is published in a separate article.
The defence lawyers
Document also asked whether the accused had been assigned defence lawyers and, if so, who they were. We can inform our readers that we had to ask this question several times before we received a reply.
Apart from Jon Christian Elden, the appointed defence lawyers are as follows:
Sugin Varatharajan of the law firm Rognstad

Sugin Varatharajan, solicitor
Photo: Rognstad Law Firm
Lawyer Fahad Shæriæti, who heads the law firm Wergeland

Farhad Shæriæti, Solicitor, Wergeland Law Firm
Photo: Wergeland Law Firm
Lawyer Syed Wali Haider Gilani at Rognstad Law Firm.

Syed Wali Haider Gilani, Solicitor, Rognstad Law Firm
Photo: Rognstad Law Firm
